Indicted in late January 2014, Kelly faced 25 charges, including money laundering and tampering with records from 2008 through 2013. The county suspended him from office in 2013.
While the jury ditched most of the charges with larger implications, such as tampering with records, they held fast to Kelly's long list of corrupt activities, finding him guilty on eight counts of theft, perjury, and engaging in a pattern of corrupt activity.
Kelly, in his sixth year as sheriff, claims he used the stolen funds to compensate informants helping him investigate illegal drug activity.
The jury, however, agreed that the former sheriff pocketed the cash from police vehicle sales as well as converted campaign check for his personal use. He spent the money, almost $14,000 intended to keep the department running, on meals, Ohio University polo shirts, and a retirement party.
"This is a public corruption case. This is a serious case. What we allege is a pattern, a long-standing pattern," Ohio attorney general Mike Dewine, who brought the charges, told the local NBC affiliate.
Scrambling, Kelly took to Facebook to slam Dewine and tried to play the charges off as political stunt.
"Sadly, the Attorney General's obsession with following a political agenda suggest that their leadership is not up to the kind of honest investigation and oversight that would lead to a clear and just assessment of the facts presented," Kelly said in an official response to the indictment.
He also said neither he nor anyone in his office had committed a crime.
With the verdict out, Kelly can't ever return to his position, which paid nearly $70,000 a year.